Pfeifer Realty Group
Real Estate Brokerage
Sanibel, FL
Realtors in Sanibel, FL
6 local real estate professionals in Sanibel, plus 8 more from nearby towns
Photo: Blind Pass, Sanibel and Captiva by Invertzoo, CC BY-SA 4.0 via Wikimedia Commons
6 real estate professionals are listed in Sanibel, Florida: 3 agents, 1 brokerage, 1 REALTOR® association, and 1 team. Sanibel has about 7,236 residents in Lee County and is part of the Cape Coral-Fort Myers, FL metro area. The typical home is valued at about $800,189 (Zillow, August 2026); over twelve months that value fell 1.8%. The closest towns with listed professionals are Fort Myers Beach (4.5 mi, 2), Cape Coral (9.1 mi, 7), and Estero (13 mi, 3).
Realtors based in Sanibel
Filter this page
Sanibel & Captiva Islands Association of Realtors
REALTOR Association
Sanibel, FL
Valerie Tutor
Real Estate Agent
Sanibel, FL
- Waterfront & Lake Homes
Tiffany & Jeff Burns
Real Estate Team
Sanibel, FL
Tina DiCharia
Real Estate Agent · Pfeifer Realty Group
Sanibel, FL
Sanibel & Captiva Islands FL Realtor
Realtor
Sanibel, FL
More realtors near Sanibel
Alex King Group
Real Estate Team · Premiere Plus Realty
Fort Myers Beach, FL 4.5 mi
- Luxury Homes
Jose Echevarria
Real Estate Agent · Keller Williams Fort Myers & The Islands
Fort Myers Beach, FL 4.5 mi
Adrianah Sells Realty
Real Estate Agent
Cape Coral, FL 9.1 mi
Cape Premier Realty
Real Estate Brokerage
Cape Coral, FL 9.1 mi
Diana Rodriguez
Real Estate Agent
Cape Coral, FL 9.1 mi
Helen Marks
Realtor
Cape Coral, FL 9.1 mi
Nick Grabowski
Realtor
Cape Coral, FL 9.1 mi
RE/MAX Realty Team
Real Estate Brokerage
Cape Coral, FL 9.1 mi
Sanibel housing market
Typical home$800K
1-year-1.8%
5-year-13.2%
10-year+15.9%
Zillow’s index estimates the middle-of-the-market home in Sanibel at around $800,189 (August 2026). Over twelve months the typical value fell 1.8%, against a 1.5% decline for Florida as a whole. Over five years the change is -13.2%. Sanibel sits 113% above the Florida typical value of $375,470.
Values: Zillow Home Value Index, August 2026.
Sanibel at a glance
| State | Florida (FL) |
|---|---|
| County | Lee County |
| Metro area | Cape Coral-Fort Myers, FL |
| Population (approx.) | 7,236 |
| Elevation | 26 ft |
| Time zone | Eastern Time |
| Realtors listed | 6 |
| Typical home value | $800,189 |
| 1-year change | -1.8% |
| License regulator | Florida Real Estate Commission (DBPR) |
| Local time | Tuesday, October 13 · 10:53 PM |
Realtors in Sanibel — common questions
How many realtors are listed in Sanibel, FL?
6 real estate professionals are listed in Sanibel today.
What is the typical home value in Sanibel?
About $800,189 according to the Zillow Home Value Index (August 2026), a change of -1.8% over one year and -13.2% over five years.
What would the monthly payment be on a typical Sanibel home?
With 10% down and a 6.5% 30-year fixed rate, principal and interest on a $800,189 home comes to roughly $4,552 a month, before taxes, insurance and any HOA dues.
Which nearby towns have realtors listed?
Fort Myers Beach (4.5 mi, 2 listings), Cape Coral (9.1 mi, 7 listings), Estero (13 mi, 3 listings), and Fort Myers (16 mi, 4 listings).