Ramsay Realtors
Real Estate Brokerage
Bay Shore, NY
Realtors in Bay Shore, NY
5 local real estate professionals in Bay Shore, plus 9 more from nearby towns
Photo: Bayshore Marina by Praiseandworship, CC BY 3.0 via Wikimedia Commons
5 real estate professionals are listed in Bay Shore, New York: 3 agents and 2 brokerages. Bay Shore has about 26,337 residents in Suffolk County and is part of the New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ-PA metro area. The typical home is valued at about $676,749 (Zillow, August 2026); over twelve months that value rose 4.9%. The closest towns with listed professionals are West Islip (3.4 mi, 1), Smithtown (9.3 mi, 1), and Kings Park (11 mi, 1).
Realtors based in Bay Shore
Filter this page
Tammy Ramsay
Real Estate Agent
Bay Shore, NY
Eric G. Ramsay IV
Realtor
Bay Shore, NY
Kevin Hill Realty
Real Estate Brokerage
Bay Shore, NY
- Commercial Property
- Rentals & Leasing
Brooke Stephens
Real Estate Agent
Bay Shore, NY
- First-Time Buyers
More realtors near Bay Shore
Howard Hanna Coach Realtors
Real Estate Brokerage
West Islip, NY 3.4 mi
Signature Premier Properties
Real Estate Brokerage
Smithtown, NY 9.3 mi
Keystone Realty USA
Real Estate Brokerage
Kings Park, NY 11 mi
REAL North Shore - Long Island, NY Realtors
Real Estate Brokerage
Greenlawn, NY 12 mi
The Island Wide Team
Real Estate Team
Patchogue, NY 12 mi
Barbara McDermott-Real Estate Associate Broker
Real Estate Agent
Massapequa, NY 12 mi
Howard Hanna Coach Realtors
Real Estate Brokerage
Northport, NY 13 mi
Kathy Martin
Real Estate Agent
Northport, NY 13 mi
Bob The Realtor
Realtor
Medford, NY 14 mi
Bay Shore housing market
Typical home$677K
1-year+4.9%
5-year+24.5%
Typical rent$3,223
Zillow’s index estimates the middle-of-the-market home in Bay Shore at around $676,749 (August 2026). Over twelve months the typical value rose 4.9%, against a 5.6% rise for New York as a whole. Zoom out to five years and values are +24.5%. Bay Shore sits 28% above the New York typical value of $526,714. Renters pay around $3,223 per month for a typical unit, +6.0% versus last year.
Values: Zillow Home Value Index and Observed Rent Index, August 2026.
Bay Shore at a glance
| State | New York (NY) |
|---|---|
| County | Suffolk County |
| Metro area | New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ-PA |
| Population (approx.) | 26,337 |
| Elevation | 30 ft |
| Time zone | Eastern Time |
| Realtors listed | 5 |
| Typical home value | $676,749 |
| 1-year change | +4.9% |
| Typical rent | $3,223/mo |
| License regulator | New York Department of State, Division of Licensing Services |
| Local time | Wednesday, October 14 · 5:55 PM |
Realtors in Bay Shore — common questions
How many realtors are listed in Bay Shore, NY?
5 real estate professionals are listed in Bay Shore today.
What is the typical home value in Bay Shore?
About $676,749 according to the Zillow Home Value Index (August 2026), a change of +4.9% over one year and +24.5% over five years.
What would the monthly payment be on a typical Bay Shore home?
With 10% down and a 6.5% 30-year fixed rate, principal and interest on a $676,749 home comes to roughly $3,850 a month, before taxes, insurance and any HOA dues.
Which nearby towns have realtors listed?
West Islip (3.4 mi, 1 listing), Smithtown (9.3 mi, 1 listing), Kings Park (11 mi, 1 listing), and Greenlawn (12 mi, 1 listing).